How to Play NKE Stock as Nike Risks Becoming a Forever Turnaround Story

How to Play NKE Stock as Nike Risks Becoming a Forever Turnaround Story

I find an uncanny similarity between the two major wars going on across the world and corporate turnarounds. Russia’s invasion of Ukraine wasn’t expected to last beyond a few days by most but is now about to enter its fifth year. The same would hold for U.S. intervention in Iran, which is increasingly seeming like one of those “forever wars,” like the ones in Iraq and Afghanistan.  

Corporate Turnaround Stories

Putting politics aside, some corporate turnarounds also seem like forever stories. Look around, and we see several companies attempting a turnaround—Peloton (PTON), Intel (INTC), Nike (NKE), Citigroup (C), and Walt Disney (DIS), to name a few. Some are indeed turnaround success stories, Citi, for instance. The company’s financial performance has improved significantly after the turnaround, and markets have given it the due credit, sending the stock north. Most others, however, risk becoming forever turnaround stories. 

More Top Stocks Daily: Go behind Wall Street’s hottest headlines with Barchart’s Active Investor newsletter.

 

Typically, a corporate turnaround involves a leadership change, cost cuts (including layoffs), a long-term strategic roadmap, and a fancy word for the process. Nike ticks all the boxes and, under CEO Elliott Hill, outlined a “Win Now” turnaround plan. Last month, it announced a new program dubbed “Pace” under which it expects to achieve around $2.5 billion in savings by fiscal year 2031.

www.barchart.com

Nike Investor Day: Key Highlights 

Now, at the Investor Day held yesterday, Nov. 17, it revealed a new “Full Stride Ahead” strategy and is targeting $5 billion in additional sales by 2031 with fiscal year 2027 as the base year. The company expects to achieve adjusted operating margins of 12%-14% by fiscal 2031 while projecting adjusted earnings per share (EPS) between $3.00 and $3.50.

Nike has been struggling with falling sales and depressed margins. At the Investor Day, it reaffirmed its guidance of a high single-digit sales decline in the current fiscal year while warning that operating income will fall more than revenue. It expects adjusted operating margins of around 6% and adjusted EPS between $1.15 and $1.35 this year. This, of course, does not include the $0.15 per share expense related to Pace restructuring.

The can has only been kicked down the road when it comes to growth expectations. Nike’s sales on a currency-neutral basis have fallen for two consecutive years, and the management expects sales to decline in the next fiscal year as well. The company termed fiscal 2028 as a “challenging year financially” and projected a modest decline in adjusted EPS. It is optimistic about returning to market-level growth in fiscal year 2029 and expects its revenues to rise faster than the market in the next two years.

www.barchart.com

Nike, which now calls itself a “Growth” company, has been starving for growth, and the only difference I noticed is that it is describing itself as a growth company even more prominently on the website. Returning to topline growth won’t be easy for Nike given the competition from new brands in the U.S. and structural weakness in China. Notably, while delivering “adjusted” profitability is relatively easier in a turnaround with aggressive belt-tightening, getting more consumers to buy your product is usually the toughest aspect. 

Nike’s Investor Day Announcements Failed to Win Over Markets

Nike’s Investor Day failed to win over markets, and the stock plummeted over 6% yesterday. While the broader market weakness also played a part, NKE fell much more than the Dow Jones Industrial Average Index ($DOWI), of which it is a constituent. The analyst community wasn’t too impressed with the Investor Day announcements or much else Nike has done lately, and still sees execution risk. 

How to Play NKE Stock Now?

I previously bought the dip in NKE, but in my most recent article, I noted that I would be selling any further rise in the stock. I have since exited the stock and am not buying it now despite the selloff. The company’s near-term outlook remains challenged, and delivering on fiscal year 2031 projections won’t be a cakewalk.

Even if we take the company’s projections at face value, the stock trades at over 10x the upper end of fiscal 2031 projected EPS, which is not tempting enough to trigger a purchase. I, however, would keep NKE stock on my watchlist and wait for further dips before buying.


On the date of publication, Mohit Oberoi had a position in: PTON , DIS . All information and data in this article is solely for informational purposes. For more information please view the Barchart Disclosure Policy here.

 

More news from Barchart

How to Play NKE Stock as Nike Risks Becoming a Forever Turnaround Story Michael Burry Is Doubling Down on Adobe Stock. Here's Why. Trump’s ‘National Champion’ Stocks Include Nvidia, Amazon, and Microsoft, Says WSJ. Will the Designation Really Matter? You Likely Haven’t Heard of This Hot Stock, But Its Roots Date Back to 1816