ATIF Holdings Ltd. Form 20-F Summary
Business context and reporting period
ATIF Holdings Limited, a British Virgin Islands holding company listed on Nasdaq under “ATIF,” filed its annual report for the fiscal year ended July 31, 2020. The filing contains audited consolidated U.S. GAAP financial statements for fiscal years 2020, 2019, and 2018; it is not a quarterly filing despite the requested “2020 Q4” period.
ATIF primarily provides going-public and financial consulting services to Chinese small and medium-sized enterprises through a PRC variable interest entity structure. On April 22, 2020, ATIF acquired approximately 51.2% of Leaping Group Co., Ltd. (“LGC”), adding multi-channel advertising, event planning, film production, and movie theater operations. LGC was consolidated from the acquisition date.
Financial condition and key metrics
| Metric | Fiscal 2020 | Fiscal 2019 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | $686,000 | $3.079 million | Down 77.7% |
| Gross profit | $459,000 | $3.079 million | Down 85.1% |
| Gross margin | 66.8% | 100.0% | Down 33.2 percentage points |
| Operating loss | $17.259 million | Operating income of $672,000 | Material deterioration |
| Net loss | $17.290 million | Net income of $429,000 | Material deterioration |
| Net loss attributable to ATIF | $14.883 million | Net income of $429,000 | Material deterioration |
| Basic and diluted loss per share | $0.37 loss | $0.01 income | Changed from profit to loss |
| Operating cash flow | $5.894 million used | $3.019 million used | Higher cash usage |
Consulting services generated $645,127, or 94.0% of total revenue. Event planning and execution generated $40,872, or 6.0%. LGC generated no multi-channel advertising or movie theater revenue during the acquisition period through July 31, 2020 because of COVID-19 restrictions.
Fiscal 2020 operating expenses were $17.718 million, including selling expenses of $2.639 million, general and administrative expenses of $6.255 million, doubtful-account provisions of $2.645 million, goodwill impairment of $5.621 million, intangible-asset impairment of $384,492, and property-and-equipment impairment of $172,728.
As of July 31, 2020, cash and cash equivalents were $428,258, compared with $6.460 million a year earlier. Total current assets were $5.237 million and total current liabilities were $7.784 million, implying a working-capital deficit of approximately $2.5 million. Total assets were $45.785 million and total liabilities were $11.167 million.
Debt was limited to $143,248 of bank borrowings. The company also reported $4.133 million of operating lease liabilities, including $750,350 current and $3.383 million noncurrent. Taxes payable were $4.004 million, principally related to assumed LGC tax liabilities.
Investing cash flow was $176,470 used, while financing cash flow was $141,983 provided, primarily from bank borrowings. The company reported no dividends and stated that it does not expect to pay dividends in the foreseeable future.
Material changes versus the prior comparable period
- Revenue fell $2.393 million, primarily because consulting clients delayed or reduced U.S. listing plans amid U.S.-China trade tensions, tighter U.S. listing rules, and COVID-19.
- Consulting customers declined from five in fiscal 2019 to two in fiscal 2020.
- Operating results were significantly affected by the April 2020 LGC acquisition and the COVID-19-related closure of movie theaters and disruption of advertising activities.
- Operating expenses increased $15.311 million, or 636.1%, driven by higher selling and administrative expenses, credit provisions, acquisition-related goodwill impairment, and other impairments.
- Accounts receivable, net, declined to $939,392 from $1.472 million despite gross receivables increasing to $2.320 million, reflecting an allowance for doubtful accounts of $1.380 million.
- Shares outstanding increased to 47,014,674 from 37,074,672, primarily due to the issuance of 9,940,002 shares in the LGC acquisition.
- LGC contributed a net loss of $4.934 million from acquisition through July 31, 2020 and had a 48.8% noncontrolling interest.
Guidance, outlook, risks, contingencies, and unusual items
Management stated that revenue and operating cash flow could continue to underperform over the following 12 months. The audited financial statements and auditor’s report include an explanatory paragraph expressing substantial doubt about the company’s ability to continue as a going concern. Management expects additional financing may be required and stated that no assurance exists that financing will be available on favorable terms or at all.
Subsequent to year-end, ATIF completed a registered direct offering on November 6, 2020, issuing 4,347,826 ordinary shares at $0.92 per share and receiving approximately $3.5 million of net proceeds. Investors also received warrants for up to 4,347,826 shares, initially exercisable at $1.10 per share, subject to adjustment provisions.
On September 22, 2020, ATIF terminated its life insurance investment and received $1.219 million after an early redemption penalty. The filing also discloses the termination of the intended Sino-fortune Securities acquisition, with a refund of approximately $130,000 after a penalty of approximately $92,000.
Material unusual items include the $5.621 million goodwill impairment, $2.645 million doubtful-account provision, $384,492 impairment of the CNNM financial and news platform, $172,728 property-and-equipment impairment, and $261,724 accrued liability related to an arbitration award in favor of Huale.
ATIF is defending litigation brought by Boustead Securities concerning fees allegedly owed in connection with the LGC transaction. The matter remained in the pleadings stage, and management stated that the outcome could not yet be predicted.
- The company’s disclosure controls and procedures were not effective as of July 31, 2020.
- Management identified four material weaknesses in internal control over financial reporting, involving accounting personnel, internal audit procedures, risk assessment, and documented closing procedures.
- The consulting business operates through a PRC VIE structure. ATIF does not directly own Qianhai and relies on contractual arrangements that could be challenged or become unenforceable under PRC law.
- PRC beneficial owners had not completed required foreign-exchange registrations under Circular 37.
- The company disclosed historical noncompliance involving employee social insurance and housing-fund contributions.
- The company had substantial concentration risk: one customer represented 91% of fiscal 2020 consolidated revenue, and two customers represented 66% of year-end accounts receivable.
- COVID-19, PRC regulatory changes, U.S.-China relations, foreign-exchange restrictions, customer credit quality, competition, and the ability to raise capital remain principal risks.
- On December 16, 2020, Nasdaq notified ATIF that it was not in compliance with the $1.00 minimum bid-price requirement and provided until June 14, 2021 to regain compliance.
Most important facts for investors to verify
- Whether the company can restore positive operating cash flow and eliminate the going-concern uncertainty.
- The status and terms of additional financing, including the November 2020 offering and warrant dilution.
- Actual post-year-end revenue from LGC’s theaters, advertising, event services, and film activities after COVID-19 restrictions eased.
- Collectability of the $2.320 million gross accounts receivable balance and the adequacy of the $1.380 million allowance.
- Settlement of approximately $4.0 million of taxes payable and any additional interest or penalties.
- Progress in remediating the four material weaknesses in internal controls.
- The status and potential exposure from the Boustead litigation and other legal proceedings.
- Compliance with Nasdaq’s minimum bid-price requirement and the potential effect of future reverse splits or other capital actions.
- The enforceability of the PRC VIE arrangements, foreign-exchange registrations, and ability to move cash from PRC operating entities to the offshore parent.