Kingsway Financial Services Inc. — Q2 2012 Form 10-Q
Reporting period: Three and six months ended June 30, 2012; unaudited. Amounts are in U.S. dollars unless noted. Kingsway is a holding company operating non-standard property and casualty insurance and insurance-services businesses.
Financial performance
| Metric | Q2 2012 | Q2 2011 | Six months 2012 | Six months 2011 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total revenue | $39.7m | $64.1m | $76.4m | $119.1m |
| Net premiums earned | $31.0m | $42.6m | $60.3m | $88.2m |
| Service fee and commission income | $8.1m | $7.8m | $17.7m | $16.8m |
| Loss from continuing operations | $(7.7)m | $(4.7)m | $(20.2)m | $(21.8)m |
| Net loss attributable to common shareholders | $(6.0)m | $(2.6)m | $(17.0)m | $(20.4)m |
| Loss per share attributable to common shareholders, diluted | $(0.59) | $(0.36) | $(1.54) | $(1.77) |
Q2 revenue fell about 38% year over year, principally reflecting lower earned premiums and a $13.7m adverse swing in the noncash fair-value change on debt (a $2.4m loss versus an $11.2m gain). First-half revenue fell about 36%; the continuing-operations loss improved modestly year over year, while Q2 loss widened. A $0.5m other-than-temporary impairment of other investments was recorded in 2012.
Insurance underwriting: Q2 gross premiums written were $32.2m, up 0.6%; net premiums written fell 6.4% to $27.7m, and net premiums earned fell 27.2% to $31.0m. For the first half, gross premiums written declined 3.9% to $71.5m, net premiums written declined 11.7% to $61.6m, and earned premiums declined 31.6%. Q2 underwriting operating loss was $3.9m, versus $9.6m; the first-half loss was $7.1m, versus $19.3m.
Underwriting ratios improved but remained unprofitable: Q2 loss ratio was 77.5% versus 86.9%, expense ratio 40.6% versus 41.1%, and combined ratio 118.1% versus 128.0%. First-half combined ratio was 117.7% versus 127.9%. A combined ratio above 100% indicates an underwriting loss. Insurance Services generated Q2 operating income of $0.9m versus $0.3m; first-half operating income was $2.6m versus $1.3m.
Cash flow and liquidity: Operating activities used $30.9m in the first half, compared with $35.5m in 2011; investing activities provided $8.4m and financing activities provided $0.1m. Cash and cash equivalents decreased $22.4m to $63.1m. Cash plus investments were $169.6m at June 30, down from $202.9m at year-end. Total assets were $349.9m and total equity $96.6m, compared with $374.1m and $116.4m at December 31, 2011.
Debt: Debt instruments had $138.4m aggregate principal and $60.3m reported fair value at June 30. Senior unsecured debentures had $27.9m fair value; subordinated debt, $20.6m; and LROC preferred units, $11.8m. The company continued its voluntary deferral of trust-preferred interest payments, with $6.0m of deferred interest included in accrued liabilities. Debt-to-total-capital and senior-debt-to-total-capital ratios were 41.0% and 24.8%, respectively; indenture thresholds cited are 50% and 35%.
Material changes and management commentary
- Management attributed lower underwriting premiums to exiting certain states, improving rate adequacy, discontinuing unprofitable programs and unaffiliated managing general agent relationships, and an Amigo quota-share reinsurance arrangement. Reduced premium volume also pressured the expense ratio because fixed costs were spread over a smaller base; management said it was taking steps to reduce fixed overhead.
- Management attributed the improved loss ratio to rate actions, discontinued unprofitable business and claims-process initiatives. Prior-year loss development was unfavorable by $0.1m in Q2 and $0.3m year to date, versus $2.1m and $1.7m in the comparable 2011 periods.
- Adoption of the insurance acquisition-cost accounting standard increased expense by $1.4m in Q2 and $2.0m year to date versus the prior accounting treatment.
- On July 3, 2012, the company effected a one-for-four share consolidation. Share counts and per-share data presented in the filing have been restated to reflect it; shares outstanding after consolidation were 13,148,971.
- No numerical earnings or premium guidance was provided. Management stated it believed liquid investments and cash were sufficient for obligations, but noted that inadequate holding-company funds could require raising capital, selling assets or restructuring debt. Insurance-subsidiary dividends require regulatory approval.
Risks, contingencies and unusual items
- On May 25, 2012, U.S. Customs demanded $12.0m plus interest from a third party under customs bonds reinsured by Lincoln General. Kingsway provided a guarantee but had not received a demand. The company said it believed it had substantial defenses and a loss was not probable; no liability was recorded. The ultimate exposure is uncertain.
- The company and subsidiaries face ordinary-course legal proceedings; possible losses could not be estimated, and individual matters could materially affect financial condition or results.
- Operating losses and reduced equity may constrain capital flexibility, trigger debt covenants or limit subsidiary dividend capacity. The company reported that insurance subsidiaries exceeded applicable minimum risk-based capital requirements at June 30.
- Key estimation risks include unpaid claims reserves, investment and debt fair values, deferred tax assets, acquisition costs, and intangible-asset and goodwill valuations. Management maintained a full valuation allowance on net deferred tax assets because future taxable income was uncertain.
- Management identified interest-rate and credit risks in investments. Approximately 89.8% of fixed maturities and short-term investments were rated A or better; this was down from 99.0% at year-end, primarily because of reinvestment in BBB/Baa securities. Management reported no subprime mortgage-backed exposure.
Important facts for investors to verify
- Whether premium contraction and underwriting losses continue, and whether cost reductions improve the combined ratio toward 100%.
- Claims-reserve adequacy, future adverse development, and the timing and amount of claim payments that drive cash needs.
- The guarantee exposure arising from the $12.0m customs demand, including any demand made on Kingsway and the outcome of its defenses.
- Holding-company liquidity, access to subsidiary dividends, debt-service capacity, interest deferral terms, and compliance with debt covenants.
- The valuation and performance of investees, particularly Atlas, and the effects of debt fair-value movements and investment impairment assessments on reported earnings.