BREAD FINANCIAL HOLDINGS, INC. annual report, FY2019

Full document

Business context and reporting period

Alliance Data Systems Corporation (now associated with the Bread Financial name in the request metadata) filed this Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2019. The filing reports annual results, not a standalone Q4 report. Its continuing businesses were LoyaltyOne, including AIR MILES and BrandLoyalty, and Card Services, primarily private-label and co-brand credit cards. Epsilon was classified as discontinued operations and sold on July 1, 2019.

Financial performance and position

  • Revenue: $5.58 billion, down 2% from $5.67 billion in 2018. Card Services generated $4.55 billion; LoyaltyOne generated $1.03 billion.
  • Profit: Operating income was $1.31 billion, down 26%; income from continuing operations was $572.6 million, down 39%. Net income was $278.0 million versus $963.1 million, with the 2019 result including a $294.6 million loss from discontinued operations. Operating margin was approximately 23.4% versus 31.0% in 2018; continuing-operations net margin was approximately 10.3% versus 16.7%.
  • Credit performance: Provision for loan losses rose 17% to $1.19 billion. Net charge-off rate was 6.1%, unchanged from 2018; delinquency was 5.8% of principal receivables at year-end, versus 5.7%. The allowance for loan loss was $1.17 billion.
  • Cash flow: Operating cash flow was $1.22 billion, down from $2.75 billion. Investing activities provided $2.86 billion, largely reflecting $4.41 billion of Epsilon-sale proceeds; financing activities used $4.09 billion. Cash and cash equivalents were $3.87 billion at year-end.
  • Debt and funding: Long-term and other debt, including current maturities, was $2.85 billion; non-recourse securitization borrowings were $7.28 billion; deposits were $12.15 billion. The company had no revolver borrowings and $750 million available under its revolving facility. Its credit-agreement leverage ratio was 1.6x, below the 3.5x maximum covenant.
  • Other metrics: Net credit card and loan receivables were $18.29 billion. Adjusted EBITDA, net, a non-GAAP measure, was $1.27 billion, down 21%. Dividends paid were $2.52 per share ($127.4 million); repurchases totaled $976.1 million.

Material changes versus the prior comparable period

  • Revenue slipped modestly, while operating income and continuing-operations earnings fell substantially. Higher loan-loss provision, portfolio valuation adjustments, funding costs, restructuring charges and debt-extinguishment costs contributed to the decline.
  • Card Services adjusted EBITDA, net declined 25% to $1.12 billion; LoyaltyOne declined 4% to $244.5 million. Corporate/Other improved to a $92.9 million adjusted EBITDA, net loss from $140.8 million.
  • The Epsilon sale brought $4.4 billion in cash proceeds. The company used sale proceeds in part to redeem $1.9 billion of senior notes and repay $500 million on its revolving facility; it later issued $850 million of 4.750% notes due 2024 and prepaid term debt.
  • Credit card and loan receivables, net, increased from $16.82 billion to $18.29 billion, while cash from operating activities fell sharply. The year-end balance sheet also reflected Epsilon’s removal from continuing operations.

Outlook, commentary, risks and unusual items

  • Management said 2019 results did not meet original expectations and cited cost-saving initiatives, including $118.1 million of restructuring and other charges, which it did not expect to recur in 2020. The filing gives no specific earnings or revenue guidance.
  • Management stated that available internal funds and other liquidity sources should meet working-capital, capital-expenditure and other business needs for at least 12 months. It expected capital expenditures to remain below 3% of annual revenue and, subject to board approval and other constraints, expected to continue quarterly dividends.
  • CECL was adopted January 1, 2020 and increased the allowance for loan loss by $644 million, recorded as a cumulative adjustment to retained earnings, net of tax. The filing warns that expected-loss estimates and economic conditions could create further allowance volatility.
  • Customer concentration is material: the ten largest clients represented 44% of consolidated revenue in 2019. One large-client contract, representing about 3% of revenue, ran through September 2020 and was not expected to renew. L Brands and affiliates represented about 11% of consolidated revenue.
  • Key risks include consumer credit deterioration, access to securitization and deposit funding, interest-rate exposure, client losses, AIR MILES redemptions and breakage estimates, foreign-exchange movements, regulation and privacy requirements, cybersecurity, and COVID-19-related disruption identified as a forward-looking risk.
  • The company recorded an Epsilon-sale pre-tax gain of $512.2 million but an after-tax loss on the sale of $252.1 million. It also accrued a $32.9 million net-of-tax contingency for its indemnification of Publicis related to a DOJ investigation involving Epsilon marketing practices; the ultimate exposure was uncertain.
  • BrandLoyalty goodwill fair value exceeded carrying value by less than 10%, leaving limited disclosed headroom. The annual impairment test found no impairment.

Most important facts for investors to verify

  1. Review the detailed notes on the $644 million CECL transition and its effects on capital, retained earnings and future loan-loss expense.
  2. Assess credit trends beyond the reported 6.1% net charge-off rate, including delinquency, portfolio mix, receivables held for sale and allowance assumptions.
  3. Confirm the status and financial impact of the expected non-renewal of the client contract representing approximately 3% of revenue.
  4. Track the DOJ investigation and Epsilon indemnification exposure, and whether the recorded contingency changes.
  5. Verify ongoing access, cost and maturity profile of deposits and securitization funding, along with debt-covenant headroom and the company’s ability to sustain dividends and repurchases.