Safehold Inc. annual report, FY2017

Filing scope and business context

Important entity clarification: The supplied filing is iStar Inc.’s Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2017, not a Safehold Inc. 10-K. It discusses Safety, Income & Growth Inc. (SAFE), which iStar launched in 2017 and in which iStar held a 37.6% interest at year-end. Figures below are for iStar unless otherwise stated.

iStar operates in real estate finance, net lease, operating properties, and land and development. It reported as a REIT and described its strategy as focusing selectively on real estate finance and net lease opportunities while monetizing operating-property and land assets.

Financial performance and position

MetricFY 2017FY 2016
Total revenue$679.2 million$455.2 million
Net income attributable to iStar$175.7 million$95.3 million
Net income allocable to common shareholders$110.9 million; $1.56 per share$44.0 million; $0.60 per share
Loss from continuing operations$40.2 million$23.4 million
Adjusted income allocable to common shareholders (non-GAAP)$214.6 million$112.6 million
Cash flow from operating activities$80.2 million$21.5 million
Cash and cash equivalents at year-end$657.7 million$328.7 million
Debt obligations, net$3.476 billion$3.390 billion
Total assets / total equity$4.731 billion / $914.2 million$4.826 billion / $1.060 billion

Annual revenue growth was led by other income and land development revenue. Interest expense was $194.7 million, down 12% year over year; average debt was $3.58 billion and reported weighted-average debt cost was 5.6%. No standard company-wide profit margin is stated in the filing. Common dividends were not declared or paid in 2017 or 2016; preferred dividends were paid.

Material changes versus the prior year

  • Reported common-shareholder income increased, but results included a $123.4 million gain from the sale of a controlling interest in the ground-lease business to SAFE. The ground-lease operations were presented as discontinued operations.
  • The Bevard land litigation settlement contributed $114.0 million of land development revenue and $123.4 million of interest and real estate-tax-related income; related land cost of sales was $106.3 million.
  • Interest income declined 18% to $106.5 million, primarily as average performing loans fell to $1.07 billion from $1.40 billion. Performing-loan yield rose to 9.8% from 8.9%.
  • Equity-method earnings fell to $13.0 million from $77.3 million, reflecting substantial prior-year investment-sale and venture-related earnings.
  • Asset impairments increased to $32.4 million from $14.5 million. Land and development assets fell to $860.3 million from $945.6 million; loans and other lending investments, net, fell to $1.301 billion from $1.450 billion.

Liquidity, debt and portfolio indicators

  • iStar reported $657.7 million of unrestricted cash at year-end. 2017 investing cash flow was $269.5 million; financing cash flow was negative $20.7 million.
  • 2017 capital-markets transactions refinanced or repaid 2017 and 2018 corporate maturities, leaving no stated corporate debt maturities until July 2019. Weighted-average debt maturity extended by 1.5 years to 4.0 years. Management reported approximately $37 million of annual expense reduction and a roughly 35-basis-point lower cost of capital.
  • Debt principal maturities were $771.7 million in 2019, $725.0 million in 2020, $790.7 million in 2021 and $1.122 billion in 2022. Debt covenants include minimum unencumbered-asset, collateral-coverage and fixed-charge requirements; cross-default provisions also apply.
  • Maximum unfunded commitments were approximately $388.6 million, with management expecting most to be funded over the following two years if conditions and milestones are met. Expected portfolio capital expenditures over the next 12 months were approximately $175–$225 million, including about $100 million for vertical construction.
  • Five non-performing loans had a net carrying value of $176.9 million, or 13.4% of the real estate finance portfolio’s carrying value. Total loan-loss reserves were $78.5 million. Performing loans had a 67% weighted-average loan-to-value ratio.
  • Commercial operating-property occupancy was 78% at year-end, versus 74% a year earlier; net-lease occupancy was 97.9%. Approximately 27.4% of in-place operating lease income was scheduled to expire over the next five years.

Outlook, commentary, risks and unusual items

  • Management said real estate finance, net lease and land and development contributed positively to 2017 earnings, and emphasized selective investment in core businesses, redevelopment and monetization. No specific earnings or revenue guidance was provided.
  • Management cited improved credit ratings from all three major rating agencies after the financing transactions, while noting unsecured ratings remained below investment grade in the risk discussion.
  • Key risks include refinancing and capital-market access, debt covenant compliance, interest-rate spread compression, borrower defaults and collateral values, development and entitlement delays, tenant credit and lease expirations, and concentration in real estate markets and asset types.
  • The company recorded $32.4 million of asset impairments and a $14.7 million loss on early extinguishment of debt. The 2017 net-income result also included the SAFE transaction gain and Bevard-related income, so reported earnings were materially affected by unusual items.
  • The filing describes the SAFE relationship as involving related management and leadership roles: iStar externally manages SAFE, and iStar’s chairman and CEO also chaired and led SAFE. iStar also retained a limited-recourse guaranty and environmental indemnity related to SAFE financing, subject to stated release conditions.
  • iStar had applied to recover more than $17 million in Bevard litigation attorneys’ fees; the amount remained subject to further court proceedings. The filing said routine litigation was not expected to have a material adverse effect based on information then available.

Important facts for investors to verify

  • Confirm whether the intended issuer is iStar Inc. or Safehold Inc.; this source is iStar’s 10-K, and SAFE’s results are not presented here as a standalone Safehold 10-K.
  • Separate recurring operating performance from the $123.4 million SAFE gain, Bevard settlement-related income, property-sale gains and other non-recurring items; review the reconciliation and assumptions behind non-GAAP adjusted income.
  • Review loan-level performance, collateral valuations, the five non-performing loans, and whether the $78.5 million reserve remains adequate.
  • Assess the 2019–2022 debt maturities, covenant headroom, variable-rate exposure, and the ability to fund commitments and planned capital expenditures while maintaining liquidity.
  • Track SAFE’s valuation and iStar’s retained ownership and guaranty exposure, along with the related-party management arrangement and exclusivity agreement.
  • Check subsequent developments in planned development spending, lease expirations, Bevard fee recovery, and the company’s decision not to pay common dividends.