A rapid resurgence in U.S. inflation numbers, with August CPI held at 3.4%, along with a dramatic spike in crude oil prices toward $100 a barrel, has been calling for a strict monetary policy measure from the nation’s central bank. Consequently, the Federal Reserve is expected to raise rates by a quarter-point at tomorrow’s FOMC meeting, with markets pricing a 92% probability — up sharply from 59% a week ago.
As higher rates raise borrowing costs, consumers' ability to spend on discretionary goods gets squeezed, placing consumer discretionary stocks directly in the crosshairs.
This environment puts a critical spotlight on consumer discretionary stocks and, by extension, exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that hold them, as investors seek to gauge how exposed the industry really is.
But before we jump into the specifics of these ETFs, let us dissect the macro dynamics connecting monetary policy to consumer behavior, evaluate high-risk stock exposure and outline strategic ETF positioning.
The Connection: How Rate Hikes Pressure Discretionary Stocks
Rate hikes hit discretionary stocks through three channels.
First, rate hikes will push credit card APRs as well as 30-year mortgage rates further up, thereby cutting disposable income for U.S. consumers. When non-essential household budgets tighten, sales velocities slow down rapidly across discretionary retail items, putting stocks like Amazon AMZN, particularly its e-commerce platform, as well as Alibaba BABA in direct line of fire.
Second, as rate hikes make debt more expensive, higher corporate funding costs can squeeze profit margins. Notably, credit-dependent businesses — such as major homebuilders and associated suppliers like Home Depot HD and automotive manufacturers like Tesla TSLA — face immediate headwind pressure as financing options become costlier.
Third, the 10-year Treasury yield in the United States is currently 5.025%, the highest since 2007, which is compressing equity growth valuations, including those for discretionary stocks.
The ETF Playbook at Bay
As rate-sensitive stocks like those mentioned above occupy central weightings within top consumer discretionary ETFs, single-stock downturns quickly translate into broader ETF performance drags.
Notably, Jefferies recently reported $528.3 million in weekly outflows from consumer discretionary ETFs as hike odds rose.
That said, history offers some comfort, with Goldman Sachs’ strategists mentioning the S&P 500 index to have averaged 9% over the 12 months following the first hike of seven prior hiking cycles (as cited in Investing.com).
As agentic AI and digital personalization are transforming retail traffic engagement, data-rich brands may enjoy an advantage in customer retention and protect their profit margins. Thus, while the consumer discretionary industry faces near-term pressure, its long-term outlook remains cautiously optimistic.
Therefore, rather than liquidating long-term consumer positions entirely, holding core ETF allocations should allow investors to capture underlying economic resilience while softening drawdowns caused by transient hawkish policy turns.
Consumer Discretionary ETFs to Hold
State Street Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR ETF XLY
This fund, with assets under management (AUM) worth $21.40 billion, offers exposure to 47 companies in specialty retail; broadline retail; hotels, restaurants and leisure; textiles, apparel and luxury goods; household durables; automobiles; automobile components; distributors; leisure products; and diversified consumer services.
AMZN holds the first spot in this fund, with 24.91% weightage, while TLSA holds the second spot with 17.75% weightage. HD holds the third spot in this fund, with 5.31% weightage.
XLY charges 8 basis points (bps) in fees. It traded at a good volume of 5.28 million shares in the last trading session.
iShares Global Consumer Discretionary ETF RXI
This fund, with net assets worth $249 million, provides exposure to 131 global companies producing non-essential goods and services. AMZN holds the first spot in this fund, with 16.63% weightage, while TLSA holds the second spot with 6.80% weightage. HD holds the third spot in this fund, with 4.36% weightage, while BABA enjoys the fourth position with 4.33% weightage.
RXI charges 37 bps in fees. It traded at a volume of 0.05 million shares in the last trading session.
ProShares Online Retail ETF ONLN
This fund, with net assets worth $59.5 million, provides exposure to 22 retail stocks that principally sell online or through other non-store channels. AMZN holds the first spot in this fund, with a 24.40% weight, while BABA holds the third position with 8.29% weightage.
ONLN charges 58 bps in fees. It traded at a volume of 0.01 million shares in the last trading session.
VanEck Consumer Discretionary TruSector ETF TRUD
This fund, with net assets worth $59.4 million, provides exposure to securities of consumer discretionary-related companies or instruments that provide exposure to consumer discretionary-related companies. AMZN holds the second spot in this fund, with a 27.59% weight, while
TSLA holds the third position with 6.72% weightage. HD enjoys the fourth position with 2.01% weight.
TRUD charges 16 bps in fees. It traded at a volume of 0.03 million shares in the last trading session.
Boost Your Portfolio with Our Top ETF Insights
Zacks' exclusive Fund Newsletter delivers actionable information, top news and analysis, as well as top-performing ETFs, straight to your inbox every week.
Don’t miss out on this valuable resource. It’s free!
Get it now >>Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research? Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days. Click to get this free report
Amazon.com, Inc. (AMZN): Free Stock Analysis Report
The Home Depot, Inc. (HD): Free Stock Analysis Report
Tesla, Inc. (TSLA): Free Stock Analysis Report
Alibaba Group Holding Limited (BABA): Free Stock Analysis Report
State Street Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR ETF (XLY): ETF Research Reports
iShares Global Consumer Discretionary ETF (RXI): ETF Research Reports
ProShares Online Retail ETF (ONLN): ETF Research Reports
This article originally published on Zacks Investment Research (zacks.com).