Business Context and Reporting Period
Company: Morningstar, Inc.
Filing Type: Form 8-K (Current Report)
Date of Report: February 4, 2011
Reporting Period: This filing serves as a Regulation FD disclosure containing responses to investor questions received through February 1, 2011. It addresses operational updates, historical financial data, and strategic outlooks rather than reporting a specific quarterly financial period.
Key Financial Metrics and Operational Data
Revenue Composition (First 9 Months of 2010):
- Contracts and Licenses: ~65%
- Subscriptions: ~17%
- Asset-based Fees: ~12%
- Other (Advertising, setup fees): ~6%
| Year | Revenue |
|---|---|
| 2009 | 478,996 |
| 2008 | 502,457 |
| 2007 | 435,107 |
| 2006 | 315,175 |
| 2000 | 74,973 |
| 1990 | 2,351 |
- Shenzhen, China: Capacity for ~1,050 employees; currently ~850 employees (single shift).
- Mumbai, India: Capacity for ~300 employees (two shifts); currently 114 employees.
- New Delhi, India: Capacity for ~225 employees (two shifts); currently 141 employees.
- Participants: >690,000
- Average Account Balance: ~$27,000
General range for products (Licensed Data, Advisor Workstation, Direct, Investment Consulting) is 90% to >100% in dollar terms. Advisor Workstation is noted as having the highest renewal rate.
Material Changes and Management Commentary
Executive Departures and Restructuring:
- Tao Huang (COO): Departed end of January 2011. Severance costs will be recognized in Q1 2011. He will remain as a consultant for acquisitions and IT transition. No direct replacement as COO is planned; a search for a Chief Technology Officer (CTO) is underway.
- Patrick Reinkemeyer (President, Morningstar Associates): Departed mid-December 2010. His role is being consolidated under Peng Chen, who now leads all global investment management operations.
- Organizational Impact: Corporate sales now reports to the CFO; LIM is part of the data division. Management asserts no short-term gaps or disruption to information flow.
- Domestic (US): Morningstar claims to be the only publisher of independent qualitative mutual fund analysis for a broad audience, though it faces competition from in-house teams at brokerages and consulting firms.
- International: Competitors vary by region, including Mercer, S&P, Lonsec, and BestInvest.
- Product Comparison: Capital IQ is not considered a close competitor to Morningstar Direct due to differing focuses (company-level data vs. investment research).
Management estimates the impact of recent Illinois state corporate tax hikes on 2009 earnings would have been nominal (less than $300,000) due to low apportionment of business to Illinois.
Guidance, Risks, and Unusual Items
Forward-Looking Statements:
The filing contains forward-looking statements subject to risks including global financial uncertainty, market volatility affecting asset-based fees, reputation damage from conflict of interest claims, fiduciary liability, industry consolidation, and database outages.
Strategic Initiatives:- Third-Party Data: Plans to add fixed-income data and expand energy, financial, and commodity data aggregation via LIM.
- Institutional Equity Research: Reported strong growth in revenue and new clients for the first nine months of 2010. Average selling price has steadily increased.
- Retirement Accounts: Strategy focuses on increasing adoption rates and average account balances to compete with Financial Engines (which reported higher average balances but fewer participants).
Investor Verification Checklist
- Q1 2011 Earnings Impact: Verify the specific dollar amount of severance costs recognized for Tao Huang in the upcoming Q1 2011 earnings report.
- CTO Appointment: Monitor for the announcement of the new Chief Technology Officer and the timeline for the IT transition.
- Revenue Mix Trends: Track the shift in revenue composition, specifically the growth of asset-based fees versus contracts, given the volatility risks cited.
- International Expansion: Verify staffing levels in Shenzhen and India against the stated capacity to assess operational scaling.
- Competitive Positioning: Assess the actual market share gains in the managed retirement account space relative to Financial Engines.