AMERICAN COASTAL INSURANCE Corp quarterly report, Q4 FY2013

Business context and reporting period

The filing is a Form 10-Q for United Insurance Holdings Corp. (UPC Insurance), a property and casualty insurer focused primarily on homeowners coverage. It writes in Florida, Massachusetts, New Jersey, North Carolina, Rhode Island and South Carolina, and reported licenses to write in New Hampshire and Texas. The supplied company metadata names American Coastal Insurance Corp.; that does not match the registrant named in this filing and should be verified.

The cover states the quarter ended December 31, 2013. However, the income statement and cash-flow statement headers repeatedly say periods ended September 30, while other notes and the MD&A refer to periods ended December 31. Accordingly, the reported period labels are inconsistent; the filing text does not provide a clear resolution. Figures below are presented as reported, not independently reconciled. Dollar amounts are in millions unless stated otherwise.

Financial results and position

Metric2013 reportedComparable 2012
Revenue, three months$63.441$37.895
Net premiums earned, three months$60.289$34.233
Net income, three months$7.351$0.983
Diluted EPS, three months$0.45$0.09
Revenue, nine months$208.080$131.234
Net premiums earned, nine months$197.378$121.968
Net income, nine months$20.342$9.705
Diluted EPS, nine months$1.26$0.91
Combined ratio, three months / nine months82.7% / 87.7%107.3% / 94.8%
Operating cash flow, nine months$106.443 in cash-flow statement; MD&A separately states $107.766$33.736 in cash-flow statement; MD&A separately states $34.312

Balance-sheet amounts at December 31, 2013: total assets were $441.230, investments $288.926, cash and cash equivalents $34.888, total liabilities $333.643, notes payable $14.706 and stockholders’ equity $107.587. The cash-flow statement gives ending cash of $33.565, which does not agree with the balance sheet. Unpaid losses and loss-adjustment expenses were $47.451; unearned premiums were $193.428. The filing reports investment and cash holdings of $323.814 in its highlights.

Gross premiums written were $106.702 for the three-month period and $381.352 for the nine-month period, versus $59.524 and $254.909, respectively, in 2012. Policies in force rose 50% to 202,454 from 135,297. The reported loss ratio was 49.2% for three months and 50.0% for nine months; the expense ratio was 33.5% and 37.7%. Nine-month net realized investment losses were $0.129, compared with gains of $2.160 in 2012. Net investment income was $3.871 versus $3.083.

Material changes versus the prior comparable period

  • Reported revenue and premiums expanded substantially, with management attributing growth to new and renewal policies, expansion across states and assumed Citizens Property Insurance Corporation policies.
  • Reported net income increased to $20.342 for nine months from $9.705; diluted EPS increased to $1.26 from $0.91. The nine-month combined ratio improved to 87.7% from 94.8%.
  • Management said three-month underlying loss costs rose by $13.219, mainly reflecting more policies and increased frequency and severity of Florida fire and lightning claims. Favorable prior-year reserve development and lower catastrophe losses affected comparisons.
  • Investments increased to $288.926 from $152.180 at the prior year-end. Accumulated other comprehensive income fell to $0.092 from $2.613, primarily reflecting unrealized investment losses associated with rising interest rates.
  • Notes payable declined from $15.882 to $14.706 on the balance sheet. The $15.0 million Florida State Board of Administration note was reported as covenant-compliant.

Outlook, risks and unusual items

Management expected premium growth to continue through expansion in existing markets, commencement of Texas operations and further state expansion. It said current capital resources and operating cash were expected to meet anticipated working-capital needs, while cautioning that future sufficiency was not assured. Management also expected market rates to remain below the portfolio’s existing yield for a period, putting pressure on reinvestment yields, and anticipated continued capital-market volatility.

The 2013–2014 catastrophe program included $441.540 million of Florida Hurricane Catastrophe Fund coverage and $360.060 million of private reinsurance coverage, subject to program terms and exposure adjustments. The company’s principal risks include catastrophe and severe weather losses, reinsurance cost and availability, claims-reserve estimation, regulation and statutory capital requirements, investment-market exposure, competition, litigation and insurer financial-strength ratings. Insurance-company dividends and repayment of the surplus note are subject to regulatory restrictions.

On November 5, 2013, the company disclosed assuming more than 18,000 Citizens policies representing approximately $63.047 million of annualized premiums; opt-outs and cancellations could reduce the amount. It declared a $0.04-per-share dividend payable in December. Management reported no material change in disclosure controls, no material change in risk factors, and no off-balance-sheet arrangements. Ordinary-course claims-related legal actions were disclosed; the filing gives no clear quantified aggregate contingency value.

Important facts for investors to verify

  • Confirm the correct issuer: the filing identifies United Insurance Holdings Corp., not American Coastal Insurance Corp.
  • Reconcile the stated December 31 reporting period with September 30 statement headers and the inconsistent cash-flow and operating-cash figures.
  • Verify the correct ending cash balance and the basis for the differing operating-cash-flow amounts in the statements and MD&A.
  • Assess whether premium growth can be sustained without further deterioration in underlying claim frequency, severity or reserve development.
  • Review statutory capital, dividend constraints, surplus-note covenants and the actual protection and cost of catastrophe reinsurance.
  • Evaluate interest-rate sensitivity and unrealized investment losses, as well as whether assumed Citizens policy premiums and policy counts persist after opt-outs and cancellations.