Business Context and Reporting Period
This Form 8-K is filed by LendingClub Corporation (noted as "Happen, Inc." in metadata) on June 22, 2016, with events reported through June 28, 2016. The filing addresses significant corporate governance changes, workforce reductions, and the results of an independent forensic review regarding investment fund valuations and historical loan origination practices.
Key Financial Metrics and Material Changes
- Restructuring Charges: The Company estimates approximately $3.0 million in charges for the quarter ended June 30, 2016, related to a workforce reduction of up to 179 positions (approximately 12% of the workforce). Cash payments are expected to conclude by September 30, 2016.
- Reimbursement Liability: An estimated $800,000 cost is anticipated to reimburse limited partners of six private investment funds managed by subsidiary LC Advisors for valuation adjustments inconsistent with GAAP.
- Investment Fund Assets: As of May 31, 2016, the six private investment funds held aggregate total assets of $1.1 billion.
- Historical Loan Irregularities: A review identified 32 loans totaling approximately $722,800 in originations and $25,000 in revenue issued in late 2009 to the former CEO and family members to artificially inflate platform volume. All loans have been repaid in full.
Management Commentary, Risks, and Unusual Items
Leadership Changes
Effective June 27, 2016, Scott Sanborn was named Chief Executive Officer and President. Hans Morris stepped down as Executive Chairman and was appointed independent Chairman of the Board.
Forensic Review Findings
An independent sub-committee review identified two material issues:
- Fund Valuation Errors: Adjustments were made to the valuation of "level 3 assets" (loans) in six private funds that were not consistent with GAAP, affecting reported returns. The Company is reimbursing adversely impacted partners and providing revised return figures.
- Investment Strategy Breach: One fund exceeded investment parameters regarding 60-month loan allocations due to non-adherence to strategy, including purchasing loans about to expire on the platform.
Governance Improvements
In response to the review, LC Advisors established a majority independent Governing Board in June 2016 to provide fiduciary oversight, approve valuation policies, and ensure adherence to investment strategies. Responsibilities for accounting and financial reporting are being realigned.
Risks and Contingencies
While the additional review is substantially complete, the Company notes it is possible that additional issues may arise in response to ongoing government requests for information.
Investor Verification Checklist
- Verify the impact of the $3.0 million restructuring charge on Q2 2016 earnings and cash flow.
- Confirm the timeline and process for the $800,000 reimbursement to limited partners of the private funds.
- Review the revised return figures for the six private investment funds to assess historical performance accuracy.
- Monitor ongoing government inquiries and any potential further disclosures regarding the forensic review.
- Assess the effectiveness of the new independent Governing Board for LC Advisors in preventing future valuation or strategy breaches.