Kingsway Financial Services Inc. — 2017 Form 10-K
Business context and reporting period. This annual report covers the fiscal year ended December 31, 2017; amounts are in U.S. dollars. Kingsway is a Canadian holding company with U.S. businesses in non-standard auto insurance, extended warranties and leased real estate. It acquired Professional Warranty Service Corporation (PWSC) on October 12, 2017, for estimated cash consideration of $9.9 million.
Financial performance and position
| Metric | 2017 | 2016 |
|---|---|---|
| Total revenue | $193.2 million | $176.6 million |
| Operating loss | $18.1 million | $6.8 million |
| Loss from continuing operations | $11.7 million | $0.7 million |
| Net income (loss) | ($11.1 million) | $0.5 million |
| Net loss attributable to common shareholders | $15.8 million | Net income of $0.2 million |
| Operating cash flow | Use of $19.0 million | Use of $15.6 million |
| Cash and cash equivalents | $44.3 million | $36.5 million |
| Total assets | $484.6 million | $501.0 million |
| Total shareholders’ equity | $43.8 million | $56.8 million |
- Insurance underwriting: Gross premiums written fell 4.4% to $127.0 million, while net premiums earned rose 2.2% to $130.4 million. The segment’s operating loss widened to $20.6 million from $8.2 million. Its combined ratio was 116.1% versus 106.8%; a ratio above 100% indicates an underwriting loss.
- Reserves: Property and casualty claims reserves were $63.7 million, up from $53.8 million. Prior-year loss estimates developed unfavorably by $20.7 million in 2017, compared with $8.1 million in 2016. Management attributed the increase mainly to higher claim severity and a backlog of claims following disruption in Mendota’s claims operation.
- Extended Warranty: Service fee and commission income rose 31.8% to $31.9 million; segment operating income improved to $4.0 million from $0.5 million. The increase included PWSC, which contributed $2.4 million of revenue and $0.9 million of operating income after acquisition.
- Leased Real Estate: Rental income was $13.4 million versus $5.4 million, reflecting the CMC acquisition and lease amendment. Segment operating income was $3.1 million versus $0.6 million.
- Cash, investments and debt: Cash and invested assets totaled $145.9 million, including $53.2 million in fixed maturities. Reported debt carrying value was $243.5 million: a $186.5 million mortgage note, $4.9 million bank loan and $52.1 million subordinated debt. Principal value of subordinated debt was $90.5 million and its interest rate floats with LIBOR. The mortgage is associated with CMC and is described as nonrecourse to Kingsway and its affiliates.
- Holding-company liquidity: Cash in Kingsway Financial Services Inc. and Kingsway America Inc. was only $0.6 million at year-end, versus $14.9 million a year earlier; it increased to $6.1 million by the filing date, primarily from investment sales. Most consolidated cash is held in subsidiaries and is not available for holding-company obligations. Insurance subsidiary dividends require regulatory approval.
Material changes and unusual items
- The insurance underwriting loss worsened substantially, driven particularly by the $20.7 million unfavorable reserve development. The company reduced policy count by approximately 12% year over year as it raised rates, revised payment terms and imposed market restrictions aimed at improving profitability.
- Net investment income declined to $2.7 million from $8.2 million, largely because the 2016 result included a $4.7 million gain on a fair-value investment. Net realized gains increased to $3.8 million from $0.4 million.
- A $17.8 million income tax benefit helped reduce the 2017 continuing-operations loss; it included a provisional $19.0 million benefit from the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. The company cautioned that the tax accounting was provisional and adjustments could be recorded through the fourth quarter of 2018.
- The change in fair value of subordinated debt generated an $8.5 million loss, compared with a $3.7 million loss in 2016. This is a non-cash mark-to-market item, but management expects continuing volatility in reported results.
- Fourth-quarter 2017 revenue was $49.5 million, and operating loss was $16.0 million. Continuing operations reported income of $0.05 million, while net loss attributable to common shareholders was $4.6 million. The annual report does not provide a clear explanation in the supplied text for the quarter-to-quarter drivers of this result.
Outlook, risks and contingencies
- No formal earnings or revenue guidance is provided. Management generally expects CMC to generate approximately $2.8 million to $3.1 million of annual income over the next three years. Material cash distributions to the holding company remain uncertain and may depend on a sale, lease restructuring or mortgage refinancing or restructuring.
- Mendota’s risk-based capital ratio was 196% at December 31, 2017, below the 200% regulatory threshold that generally prompts corrective action. It filed a capital plan in March 2018, subject to regulatory approval. Mendota and MCC also entered into 50% quota-share reinsurance agreements effective February 1, 2018; Mendota’s agreement excludes California premiums.
- All U.S. insurance subsidiaries were restricted from paying dividends to the holding company without regulatory approval. The company warns that subsidiary losses, capital requirements and holding-company liquidity needs may constrain operations and financing.
- Other principal risks include uncertain adequacy of loss reserves, concentrated exposure to six states representing 90.1% of insurance premiums, intense competition, investment-market volatility, rising LIBOR costs, and the ability to manage acquisitions and restructuring. The company also disclosed an unquantified potential exposure under indemnity agreements related to customs bonds reinsured by former subsidiary Lincoln General; no liability was recorded. Ordinary-course litigation exposures could not be estimated.
- The company reported $882.4 million of U.S. federal net operating loss carryforwards, but use depends on future taxable income and may be restricted by ownership changes or expiration. A full valuation allowance is maintained on most deferred tax assets.
- Management stated disclosure controls and internal control over financial reporting were effective at year-end; the auditor gave unqualified opinions on the financial statements and internal controls. PWSC was excluded from the internal-control assessment, representing approximately 1.3% of revenue and 2.9% of assets.
Important facts for investors to verify
- Whether Mendota’s capital plan is approved and the new quota-share arrangements improve its RBC position as intended.
- Whether the 2017 reserve deterioration reflects claims inventory clean-up and industry trends that have now stabilized, or signals further adverse development.
- How much of consolidated cash is restricted or otherwise unavailable to the holding company, and whether the reported $6.1 million of post-year-end holding-company liquidity is sufficient for debt service and operating costs.
- The final purchase-price allocation for PWSC and its subsequent operating performance; the 2017 acquisition accounting remained subject to true-up and finalization.
- The final accounting impact of the Tax Act, the realizability and ownership-change limitations on tax attributes, and any future tax payments outside the U.S. tax group.
- The distinction between the $90.5 million principal amount of floating-rate subordinated debt and its $52.1 million fair-value carrying amount, along with the fixed-rate mortgage debt and its nonrecourse terms.