Kingsway Financial Services Inc. — Q1 2017 Form 10-Q
Business context and reporting period. Unaudited results cover the three months ended March 31, 2017, compared with Q1 2016. Kingsway is a Canadian holding company whose U.S. subsidiaries operate in non-standard auto insurance, insurance services and leased real estate. Amounts below are U.S. dollars.
Financial performance and position
- Revenue: $46.7 million, up 26.7% from $36.9 million. Net premiums earned rose to $32.9 million from $29.4 million; service fee and commission income rose to $6.6 million from $5.3 million. The $3.3 million of rental income came from CMC, acquired in July 2016.
- Profitability: Operating loss narrowed to $0.6 million from $2.8 million. Net loss was $1.5 million, essentially unchanged from $1.5 million; loss attributable to common shareholders was $1.7 million versus $1.5 million. Loss per share was $0.08 in both periods.
- Segments: Insurance Underwriting posted a $0.7 million operating loss versus $0.2 million; its combined ratio increased to 102.4% from 101.2%, indicating underwriting losses. Insurance Services improved to $0.6 million operating income from a $0.2 million loss. Leased Real Estate contributed $0.9 million operating income; there was no comparable 2016 segment result.
- Notable earnings items: Net investment income was $0.7 million versus a $0.1 million loss, and equity income from investee was $2.4 million versus a $0.1 million loss. These benefits were partly offset by a $1.9 million noncash loss from the increased fair value of subordinated debt; Q1 2016 included a $2.5 million gain on that debt. The company also recorded a $0.25 million intangible impairment.
- Cash flow: Operating activities used $7.8 million, compared with $4.1 million used in Q1 2016. Investing activities provided $5.7 million; financing activities used $0.6 million. Cash declined $2.8 million to $33.7 million.
- Balance sheet and liquidity: At March 31, total assets were $497.7 million, total liabilities $436.5 million, and shareholders’ equity $54.8 million. Investments totaled $120.9 million. Debt carrying value was $234.7 million, against principal of $268.7 million, including a $189.2 million note payable and $45.5 million subordinated debt. Holding-company liquidity was $11.7 million, down from $14.9 million at year-end; management estimated this covered about 14 months of recurring operating expenses and subordinated-debt interest, excluding extraordinary or transaction-driven needs. Consolidated cash also includes subsidiary cash not generally available to the holding company.
Changes, outlook and risks
- Insurance premiums earned increased 11.9%; gross premiums written increased 2.8%. Management attributed the changes to shifts in state mix and competitive conditions. The underwriting combined ratio deteriorated, and the segment’s operating loss increased, partly due to severance expense.
- The CMC lease amendment provides for an aggregate $25.0 million of additional rent through May 2034. Management expects CMC to generate approximately $2.7–$3.1 million of annual income over the next four years. Any material cash available to Kingsway’s holding company remains uncertain; service-fee payments depend on specified events, and the amendment itself did not trigger them.
- No formal company-wide earnings guidance is provided. Management cautions that interim results may not indicate full-year results and disclaims an obligation to update forward-looking statements.
- Insurance loss reserves depend on estimates and may differ materially from eventual claims. Prior-year property-and-casualty reserves had $0.2 million of unfavorable development, primarily at Mendota. The company reported no investment impairment write-downs; it judged $0.9 million of gross unrealized investment losses to be temporary.
- Holding-company cash access is constrained: U.S. insurance subsidiaries could not pay dividends without regulatory approval. A guarantee relating to customs bonds reinsured by former subsidiary Lincoln General has undetermined potential exposure, with no liability recorded. Various legal proceedings are outstanding; potential losses cannot currently be estimated, and an individual matter could materially affect results or financial condition. Unfunded investment commitments were $1.6 million.
- Market risks include interest-rate and equity-price movements. A 100-basis-point increase in LIBOR would increase annual interest expense by approximately $0.9 million; a 100-basis-point move in rates was estimated to change fixed-maturity fair value by approximately $1.45 million in the opposite direction.
- Disclosure controls were judged ineffective due to an unremediated material weakness in income-tax accounting for non-routine transactions. Management was pursuing remediation but had not tested it because no non-routine transaction had occurred since year-end 2016.
Key facts investors should verify
- Whether the Insurance Underwriting combined ratio and claims experience improve, and whether reserve estimates remain adequate.
- How much of the reported improvement depends on CMC, investment gains and equity-method income, versus recurring operating performance.
- Whether holding-company liquidity remains sufficient given operating cash outflow, restricted subsidiary cash and debt-service obligations.
- Whether the CMC lease amendment translates into distributable cash, and the timing and cost of any service-fee-triggering event.
- Progress in remediating and testing the income-tax accounting material weakness, and developments in the unquantified guarantee and legal contingencies.