Kingsway Financial Services Inc. — Q3 2016 Form 10-Q
Business context and reporting period. Canadian holding company with U.S. operations in non-standard auto insurance, insurance services, and leased real estate. This unaudited report covers the three and nine months ended September 30, 2016; amounts below are in U.S. dollars. CMC, acquired July 14, 2016, contributed leased-real-estate results for part of the period, limiting comparability.
Financial results and position
| Metric | Q3 2016 | Q3 2015 | Nine months 2016 | Nine months 2015 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total revenue | $45.8m | $38.6m | $123.8m | $121.8m |
| Operating income (loss) | $1.0m | ($1.8m) | ($2.9m) | ($0.6m) |
| Continuing-operations income (loss) | $1.6m | ($0.9m) | ($1.9m) | ($9.3m) |
| Net income (loss) | $1.6m | ($0.9m) | ($0.8m) | $3.4m |
| Net income (loss) attributable to common shareholders | $1.4m | ($0.9m) | ($0.7m) | $3.1m |
| Basic EPS, continuing operations | $0.07 | ($0.05) | ($0.09) | ($0.49) |
- Revenue and operating trends: Q3 net premiums earned were $32.9m, up from $29.2m; service fees and commissions were $6.3m, versus $6.2m. CMC added $2.4m of rental income and $0.7m of segment operating income in Q3. Nine-month premium revenue was $94.2m, compared with $88.4m.
- Insurance underwriting: Combined ratio was 100.9% in Q3 and 100.7% year to date, compared with 101.1% in both prior-year periods. Ratios above 100% indicate underwriting loss. The Q3 loss ratio increased to 76.8% from 73.5%; expense ratio improved to 24.1% from 27.6%. The expense ratio benefited in part from a one-time $0.5m litigation settlement benefit.
- Cash flow: Nine-month operating cash used was $11.1m; investing cash used was $9.1m; financing cash used was $0.7m. Cash and cash equivalents declined $21.0m to $30.7m. Management attributed operating cash use mainly to increased receivables, lower unpaid-loss reserves, and the noncash deconsolidation gain, partly offset by higher unearned premiums.
- Debt and liquidity: At September 30, total liabilities were $389.8m and shareholders’ equity was $42.6m. The balance sheet included a CMC note payable with a $190.9m carrying value ($179.4m principal at period-end) and subordinated debt carried at fair value of $38.8m against $90.5m principal. CMC’s mortgage is nonrecourse to Kingsway and its affiliates; rental cash is applied to mortgage principal and interest.
- Holding-company liquidity was $6.2m, down from $13.2m at year-end 2015, which management estimated covered approximately six months of interest and regularly recurring operating expenses. Consolidated cash includes subsidiary cash not considered available for holding-company obligations; insurance-subsidiary dividends require regulatory approval.
Material changes and unusual items
- CMC acquisition added leased real estate, $2.4m of rental revenue in the quarter, a $109.1m acquired-lease intangible, and the associated mortgage. Its preliminary purchase accounting remained subject to finalization.
- A 26.7% retained interest in 1347 Investors after its transaction-related ownership dilution led to deconsolidation and a noncash $5.6m Q3 gain. This materially supported quarterly earnings.
- Nine-month 2016 results included a $1.1m after-tax earnout gain on the 2015 sale of ARS. Prior-year nine-month results included $12.7m of after-tax discontinued-operations income and disposal gains, helping explain the change from prior-year net income to a 2016 net loss.
- Q3 included a $2.5m loss from an increase in the fair value of subordinated debt; nine-month results instead included a $1.1m fair-value gain. Such noncash valuation movements add earnings volatility.
- Insurance Underwriting gross premiums written rose 18.6% in Q3 and 13.1% year to date, reflecting state-mix changes and growth in Florida, Texas, and Nevada; the company stopped accepting new business in Virginia in Q3 2015.
Outlook, risks, and contingencies
- The filing provides no specific earnings or revenue guidance. Management said available liquidity sources were believed sufficient to meet holding-company obligations, but cautioned that those sources may not be available when needed.
- Management highlighted uncertainty in reserving for unpaid losses; actual claims and settlement costs may differ materially from estimates. It also said future reserve development cannot be predicted and could materially affect a period’s results.
- Key exposures include interest-rate, credit, equity-market, and investment-valuation risks; approximately 90.2% of fixed maturities were rated A or better. Unfunded commitments to limited-liability investments were $1.8m.
- Various legal actions are pending; the company could not estimate potential losses, and an individual matter could materially affect financial condition or results. A customs-bond indemnity exposure was not determinable and no liability was recorded.
- Management concluded disclosure controls were effective, but excluded recently acquired CMC from its assessment while evaluating CMC’s procedures. No material risk-factor changes from the 2015 Form 10-K were reported.
Important facts for investors to verify
- Whether CMC’s final purchase-price allocation, lease valuation, and debt carrying value differ materially from preliminary estimates.
- The sustainability of underwriting performance, particularly rising loss ratios, geographic concentration, and reliance on favorable prior-year reserve development and the one-time settlement benefit.
- Holding-company cash needs and access to cash, given the decline in holding liquidity, restrictions on insurance-subsidiary dividends, and CMC rental cash being directed to mortgage service.
- The quality and future development of loss reserves, investment valuations, and subordinated-debt fair-value assumptions.
- Potential effects of legal proceedings, the unrecorded customs-bond indemnity exposure, and the $1.8m unfunded investment commitment.