UBS Group AG current report, Q4 FY2015

Full document

Business Context and Reporting Period

This Form 6-K, filed on November 30, 2015, by UBS Group AG and UBS AG, provides updated risk factor disclosures. The filing does not contain specific financial results for a reporting period but rather outlines strategic, regulatory, and operational risks affecting the Group's future performance and capital position.

Key Financial Metrics and Capital Position

The filing does not provide specific revenue, profit, or cash flow figures for the period. However, it highlights the following capital and risk-weighted asset (RWA) metrics:

  • Capital Return Objective: UBS commits to returning at least 50% of net profit to shareholders, contingent on maintaining a fully applied CET1 capital ratio of at least 13% and a post-stress fully applied CET1 ratio of at least 10%.
  • Operational Risk RWA: As of September 30, 2015, an incremental operational risk capital charge of CHF 13.3 billion was added to RWA to cover litigation, regulatory matters, and contingent liabilities.
  • Projected RWA Increases: Due to FINMA multipliers on Swiss residential mortgages and investment bank corporates, UBS expects an aggregate RWA increase of CHF 5 to 6 billion annually from 2015 through 2018, and CHF 2 billion in 2019.
  • Effective Tax Rate: Excluding deferred tax asset (DTA) reassessments, the expected effective tax rate for 2015 is approximately 25%.

Material Changes and Regulatory Developments

Significant regulatory changes in Switzerland and globally are materially impacting UBS's business model and capital requirements:

  • Swiss TBTF Proposal: The Swiss Federal Council proposed a "Too Big To Fail" regime requiring a going concern capital requirement of 5% of Leverage Ratio Denominator (LRD) and 14.3% of RWA for internationally active Swiss Systemically Relevant Banks (SRB). A "gone concern" requirement of 5.0% of LRD and 14.3% of RWA is also proposed.
  • Structural Changes: To improve resolvability, UBS completed the squeeze-out of UBS AG minority shareholders (September 2015), transferred Swiss Retail & Corporate and Wealth Management to UBS Switzerland AG, and established UBS Americas Holding LLC as an intermediate holding company for US operations.
  • FX and Interest Rates: The Swiss National Bank's (SNB) discontinuation of the EUR/CHF floor in January 2015 and the adoption of negative interest rates have strengthened the Swiss franc and reduced net interest income potential.

Outlook, Risks, and Management Commentary

Management identifies several critical risks that could adversely affect strategy execution and profitability:

  • Regulatory Uncertainty: Divergent regulations across jurisdictions (Switzerland, US, UK, EU) regarding capital, liquidity (LCR/NSFR), and structural reform (e.g., ring-fencing, subsidiary requirements) create operational inefficiencies and higher costs.
  • Legal and Litigation: UBS faces ongoing investigations and settlements related to LIBOR, foreign exchange, and precious metals. The termination of a non-prosecution agreement (NPA) with the US DOJ in May 2015 led to a guilty plea and a USD 203 million fine. Future penalties remain difficult to estimate.
  • Wealth Management Dynamics: Net new money inflows are increasingly coming from lower-margin segments (Asia Pacific, ultra-high net worth) replacing higher-margin cross-border European clients. Negative interest rates and regulatory changes (e.g., "retrocessions" fees) are pressuring margins.
  • Legacy Portfolio: Remaining Non-core and Legacy Portfolio positions are illiquid and complex, posing risks of significant losses if market conditions deteriorate or if exit strategies are delayed.
  • Deferred Tax Assets (DTA): The valuation of DTAs is highly sensitive to future profitability forecasts. A deviation in earnings, particularly in the US, UK, or Switzerland, could trigger substantial write-downs, significantly increasing the effective tax rate.

Investor Verification Checklist

  • Verify the impact of the proposed Swiss TBTF capital requirements on UBS's ability to meet its 13% CET1 target and maintain dividend payouts.
  • Monitor the status of ongoing regulatory investigations (LIBOR, FX, precious metals) and potential additional fines or settlements.
  • Assess the progress of the "subsidiarization" strategy in the US, UK, and Switzerland and the associated operational costs and capital inefficiencies.
  • Review the composition of Wealth Management inflows to confirm the shift toward lower-margin segments and its impact on Return on Invested Assets (ROIA).
  • Track the valuation of Deferred Tax Assets (DTAs) and the assumptions regarding future profitability in key jurisdictions to gauge potential earnings volatility.
  • Examine the liquidity and exit strategy for the remaining Non-core and Legacy Portfolio positions.