LendingClub Corporation — Q3 2023 Form 10-Q
Reporting period: Quarter ended September 30, 2023; comparisons are primarily year over year, with nine-month results also shown. The filing is for LendingClub Corporation (NYSE: LC), not Happen, Inc. Unless stated otherwise, amounts below are in millions of dollars.
Business context and financial results
LendingClub operates a digital marketplace lending business and a regulated bank through LendingClub Bank. Rising rates and economic uncertainty weighed on investor demand for marketplace loans; the company said it responded with Structured Program transactions, expense management, and a greater share of lending retained on balance sheet.
| Metric | Q3 2023 | Q3 2022 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total net revenue | $200.8 | $304.9 | Down 34% |
| Marketplace revenue | $60.9 | $173.8 | Down 65% |
| Net interest income | $137.0 | $123.7 | Up 11% |
| Provision for credit losses | $64.5 | $82.7 | Down 22% |
| Non-interest expense | $128.0 | $186.2 | Down 31% |
| Net income | $5.0 | $43.2 | Down 88% |
| Diluted EPS | $0.05 | $0.41 | Down from $0.41 |
| Net interest margin | 6.9% | 8.3% | Down 1.4 percentage points |
For the first nine months of 2023, total net revenue was $679.0 million, down 27%; net income was $28.8 million, versus $266.1 million. The 2022 nine-month result included a $140.3 million deferred-tax valuation-allowance release, making the reported net income comparison unusually large. Nine-month diluted EPS was $0.27 versus $2.56.
Balance sheet, cash flow, credit and capital
- Liquidity and deposits: Cash and cash equivalents were $1.31 billion at September 30, up from $1.06 billion at year-end 2022. Deposits were $7.00 billion, up from $6.39 billion; approximately 86% were FDIC-insured. LC Bank reported $3.76 billion in available borrowing capacity, including $3.11 billion at the Federal Reserve Discount Window.
- Loans and credit: Loans and leases held for investment, net, were $4.89 billion, versus $4.71 billion at year-end. The allowance was $350.5 million, or 6.7% of amortized-cost HFI loans, compared with 6.5% at year-end. Q3 net charge-off ratio was 5.1%, versus 2.1% a year earlier; nonaccrual HFI loans and leases were $50.0 million, or 1.0%, versus $34.8 million and 0.7% at year-end.
- Debt: Reported borrowings were $10.7 million, down from $74.9 million at year-end; retail notes, certificates and secured borrowings at fair value were another $18.1 million, down from $55.4 million. Deposits are the principal funding source.
- Capital: At September 30, LendingClub Corporation reported CET1 capital ratio of 16.9%, total capital ratio of 18.2%, and Tier 1 leverage ratio of 13.2%. LC Bank reported 15.1%, 16.5%, and 11.8%, respectively. Both were above applicable minimums and stated commitments.
- Cash flow: In the first nine months, operating activities used $321.8 million, investing activities provided $67.9 million, and financing activities provided $479.7 million. The operating cash outflow primarily reflected a $590.4 million net increase in loans held for sale; the company accumulated loans for an extended-seasoning program.
- Other balance-sheet item: AFS securities had fair value of $795.7 million against amortized cost of $872.3 million, including $81.2 million of gross unrealized losses. Management attributed substantially all unrealized losses to higher interest rates and said it did not intend, and was not more likely than not required, to sell before recovery.
Material changes and unusual items
- Q3 loan originations were $1.51 billion, down 25% sequentially and 57% year over year. Marketplace originations were $1.18 billion, down 50% year over year; HFI originations were $326.3 million, down 72%.
- Marketplace revenue fell sharply as volumes and sale prices weakened. Net fair value adjustments were a loss of $41.4 million in Q3, versus a loss of $0.6 million a year earlier, primarily due to lower loan sale prices. Servicing fees rose 38% year over year to $32.8 million, helped by a one-time recovery of volume-based purchase incentives and a servicing-asset fair-value increase.
- Higher deposit funding costs constrained margin: Q3 interest expense on deposits was $69.5 million versus $15.2 million a year earlier. Management expected net interest margin pressure to continue through the remainder of 2023.
- Credit provision declined year over year, but management cited higher expected losses and a less favorable economic outlook as offsets to lower HFI origination volumes. The allowance and net charge-off metrics increased from prior comparison points.
- In October 2023, after quarter-end, the company reduced its workforce by 172 employees, or 14%, and estimated annualized compensation and benefits savings of $30–$35 million compared with Q2 2023.
- Beginning in Q2 2023, LendingClub resumed sponsoring Structured Program transactions, retaining senior asset-backed securities as well as required risk-retention interests and selling residual certificates. It also began accumulating HFS loans for an extended-seasoning program; $362.8 million of HFS loans were on the balance sheet at quarter-end.
- The company entered credit-support arrangements with certain loan-sale investors. Maximum exposure was $3.8 million; fair value was $3.3 million, and Q3 earnings included a $2.3 million loss. It also entered $1.5 billion notional interest-rate swaps during Q3 to hedge fixed-rate loan fair-value exposure.
Outlook, risks and contingencies
Management said higher interest rates, weaker marketplace investor demand, and macroeconomic volatility were adverse to the business and expected these headwinds to persist. It expected $60 million of capital expenditures for 2023, principally for platform development and regulatory compliance. Management stated that cash, liquid AFS securities, borrowing capacity, and projected cash flows were sufficient for liquidity needs over the next twelve months and beyond.
Key risks include borrower credit deterioration, further deposit-cost increases and margin pressure, subdued investor demand and lower loan-sale pricing, recession and inflation exposure, and regulatory or legal outcomes. Federal student loan payments resumed in October 2023; the company estimated that borrowers with resumed federal student payments represented about 20% of outstanding LendingClub loan principal and said the impact remained uncertain. The filing also describes ongoing regulatory examinations, investigations, inquiries, lawsuits, and customary loan repurchase obligations; it does not provide a clear estimate of reasonably possible losses for the described matters.
The company’s stated commitments to maintain capital ratios above specified levels with regulators applied until February 2024. Management reported effective disclosure controls and no material Q3 change in internal control over financial reporting.
Important facts for investors to verify
- Whether marketplace investor demand, loan sale prices, and origination volumes stabilize, and whether the extended-seasoning and Structured Program strategies support revenue without materially increasing balance-sheet risk.
- Whether credit losses continue to rise: in particular, the 5.1% Q3 net charge-off ratio, the 6.7% allowance ratio, and delinquency and nonaccrual trends.
- Whether deposit pricing and mix sustain further net interest margin pressure, and whether the stated liquidity and borrowing capacity remain available under stressed conditions.
- Whether the October workforce reduction delivers the estimated $30–$35 million annualized savings, and how those savings compare with revenue declines and planned capital spending.
- How the resumed federal student loan payments affect borrower performance, alongside any developments in regulatory examinations, litigation, credit-support obligations, or capital commitments after February 2024.
- How much of reported earnings is recurring: Q3 servicing revenue included a one-time incentive recovery, while prior-year nine-month earnings benefited materially from a deferred-tax valuation-allowance release.