LendingClub Corporation — 2013 Form 10-K
Entity note: The request identifies Happen, Inc., but the filing is for LendingClub Corporation and subsidiaries. The filing covers the fiscal year ended December 31, 2013; fourth-quarter figures are also reported. LendingClub is an online marketplace facilitating consumer loans and connecting borrowers with individual and institutional investors.
Financial and operating highlights
- Annual results: Loan originations were $2.065 billion. Non-interest revenue was $98.0 million and net revenue was $98.0 million. Net income was $7.3 million, compared with a $4.2 million loss for the nine months ended December 31, 2012. Adjusted EBITDA, a non-GAAP measure, was $15.2 million, or 16% of net revenue.
- Fourth quarter: Originations were $698.4 million, versus $263.6 million in Q4 2012. Non-interest revenue was $33.5 million and net revenue was $33.5 million, versus $12.6 million and $12.0 million, respectively, in Q4 2012. Net income was $2.9 million, versus a $0.8 million loss. Q4 net income was approximately 8.5% of net revenue.
- Revenue mix: FY2013 origination fees were $85.9 million, servicing fees $3.5 million, management fees $3.1 million, and other revenue $5.5 million. Reported loan interest income of $187.5 million was nearly offset by $187.4 million of interest expense on Notes and Certificates; net interest income was $60,000.
- Costs and margins: Operating expenses were $90.7 million, up 176% against the reported nine-month 2012 transition period; management attributed the increase mainly to added staff, marketing, and costs supporting higher loan volume. Revenue yield was 4.7%, versus 4.8% in the transition period. The annual-period comparison is not like-for-like.
- Cash flow and liquidity: Operating cash flow was positive $1.1 million; investing cash flow was negative $1.121 billion, principally reflecting loan purchases; financing cash flow was positive $1.116 billion, principally Notes and Certificates issuance net of repayments. Cash and cash equivalents were $49.3 million and restricted cash was $12.2 million at year-end.
- Balance sheet and funding: Total assets were $1.943 billion, total liabilities $1.875 billion, and stockholders’ equity $68.1 million. Loans at fair value were $1.829 billion; Notes and Certificates at fair value were $1.840 billion. These financing obligations largely correspond to loans and their payments are dependent on borrower collections; they should not be read as conventional corporate borrowing alone. No loans payable remained at year-end.
- Credit performance: Public Policy Loans outstanding were $2.189 billion at Q4-end, with a 1.50% delinquency rate and a 3.35% annualized charge-off rate for the quarter. The filing reports a 3.29% default and charge-off rate for all loans as of year-end. Historical performance is not presented as a guarantee of future results.
Changes and notable developments
- Annual originations rose from $717.9 million in calendar 2012 to $2.065 billion in 2013, while assets under management increased from $286.7 million to $740.2 million. Calendar-year comparisons should be interpreted cautiously because LendingClub changed its fiscal year-end; the audited 2012 comparison in the statements covers only nine months.
- The company moved from losses in prior reported periods to $7.3 million of net income in 2013. It had an accumulated deficit of $50.3 million at year-end.
- LendingClub began selling whole loans to third-party institutions in late 2012; whole-loan sales with servicing retained reached $446.2 million in 2013. It adopted fair-value accounting for these sales effective July 1, 2013.
- A small-business loan pilot launched in March 2014, after the reporting date, with loans of $15,000 to $100,000 and institutional investors during the pilot.
Outlook, risks, and contingencies
- Management expected loan volume and fee revenue to grow, but the filing provides no specific numerical guidance. It stated that current cash was sufficient for current liquidity needs and anticipated positive operating cash flows, while noting growth-plan assumptions could prove incorrect.
- Key risks include dependence on WebBank as loan issuer, evolving lending and securities regulation, potential state usury or licensing challenges, and the possibility that LendingClub could be recharacterized as a lender. Management said it believed it was in substantial compliance; the business model’s regulatory treatment remained subject to uncertainty.
- Borrower defaults, economic deterioration, unverified borrower information, and model-estimation risk could impair loan and investor performance. Many borrower details are not independently verified; about 79% of listed applicants had employment or income verified in 2013.
- Notes are unsecured obligations of LendingClub, not direct claims against borrowers, and investor payments depend on collections on corresponding loans. Bankruptcy, servicing interruption, or problems transferring servicing could delay or reduce investor payments. The backup servicer’s ability to perform is not assured.
- Fair values rely on Level 3 discounted-cash-flow estimates. Management identified credit-loss and discount-rate assumptions as significant; changes in these estimates can affect reported values and earnings.
- A credit-support agreement with an investor could require up to $5.0 million of pledged cash; $3.4 million was restricted at year-end. Losses had not exceeded the contractual threshold, and no liability was recorded. Management did not expect a material effect from ordinary-course legal matters.
- The filing reports effective disclosure controls and no material weakness identified by management; the external auditor did not audit internal control over financial reporting. Grant Thornton was replaced by Deloitte in September 2013.
Investor verification priorities
- Confirm the issuer: this filing is LendingClub Corporation, not Happen, Inc.
- Review the complete audited statements and notes, especially the fair-value methodology, Level 3 assumptions, and loan-loss and vintage-performance disclosures.
- Reconcile operating cash flow and liquidity with the rapid growth in loan purchases, Notes and Certificates, and restricted cash; distinguish investor funds and pass-through financing from unrestricted corporate resources.
- Assess whether originations, investor funding, and assets under management remain balanced, and whether borrower credit performance supports the reported growth and pricing assumptions.
- Evaluate WebBank dependence, state licensing and usury exposure, backup servicing arrangements, and the credit-support agreement; check for developments after December 31, 2013.
- Use caution in comparing annual results with 2012: the company changed its fiscal year-end, and the audited comparative period is nine months rather than a full year.